top of page
BRAND PERFORMANCE
Apparel
Patagonia — 95
A global outdoor brand that’s built sustainability into how it operates, not just what it sells.
Uses a high percentage of recycled materials, works with bluesign® and Fair Trade, and openly shares its supplier list.
Materials: Recycled fabrics, bluesign®, RDS down, PFC-free
Labor: Fair Trade factories, full supplier transparency
Longevity: Worn Wear repair and resale
Where they lose points: Not everything is fully recycled yet, and scale adds complexity
Melanzana — 88
A small, Colorado-based brand focused on local production and simplicity over scale.
Built on a fully local manufacturing model with direct control over labor and production. Uses USA-sourced Polartec fleece and avoids chemical treatments like PFCs, keeping operations intentionally small.
Materials: Polartec fleece, USA sourced, no PFC treatment
Labor: 100% local manufacturing, direct employment
Longevity: Lifetime repair support
Where they lose points: Limited use of certified materials and minimal formal reporting or third-party verification
Smartwool — 82
A performance brand centered around merino wool and natural fiber systems.
Uses ZQ-certified merino wool, which ensures animal welfare and environmental standards, and supports this with published sustainability reporting and third-party audits.
Materials: ZQ-certified merino, recycled blends
Labor: Responsible Wool Standard alignment, third-party audits
Longevity: Durable wool reduces replacement frequency
Where they lose points: Still relies on synthetic blends and does not offer a formal repair or circularity program
Icebreaker — 81
A merino-based apparel company built around traceability and natural materials.
Uses ZQ-certified wool with farm-level traceability and operates under a published Code of Practice aligned with global labor standards. Focuses on reducing synthetic reliance through fiber choices.
Materials: ZQ-certified merino, farm traceable
Labor: Code of Practice, Social Labour Convergence alignment
Longevity: Lifetime guarantee, repair guidance
Where they lose points: Limited formal repair infrastructure and less transparency compared to top-tier leaders
Outdoor Research — 78
A technical gear brand known for durability and product guarantees.
Uses bluesign® approved fabrics and is working toward broader adoption of PFC-free materials. Its strongest differentiator is a perpetual repair guarantee that keeps products in use longer.
Materials: bluesign® approved fabrics, recycled insulation increasing, PFC-free in progress
Labor: Code of conduct published, audit systems developing
Longevity: Perpetual Guarantee, repair any product
Where they lose points: Incomplete material transition and limited public transparency into factory-level practices
bottom of page